Charlotte-Mecklenburg Historic Landmarks Commission

Agenda – HLC Meeting

The Historic Landmarks Commission will meet on Monday, October 14 at 6pm. This will be a hybrid meeting and visitors should plan to access the meeting remotely. If you need special accommodations, please contact the Historic Landmarks office at 980-314-7660.

For those interested in speaking at the meeting, please register by 4pm on October 14 by emailing historiclandmarkscommission@mecknc.gov. Note: Registration in advance is required to make public comments.


1.  Adoption of the Consent Agenda

a.  Approval of September HLC Minutes

2.  Chair’s Report: Brian Clarke

3.  Public Comment Period

Registration in advance is required to make public comments. Public comments can be up to 3 minutes per person and there will be no response from Commissioners.  

4.  Public Hearings

Registration in advance is encouraged but not required to speak during the public hearings. You may register by either emailing historiclandmarkscommission@mecknc.gov by 4pm on October 14 OR stating in the Teams chat BEFORE the public hearing starts that you want to speak. Public comments can be up to 3 minutes per person.  

a.  John Eli Brattain House, 305 South Main Street, Davidson

Map of Property

Designation Report

SHPO Staff Comments

Designation would include the interior and exterior of the building and the approximately 0.322 acres of land associated with tax parcel #00701884.

John Eli Brattain House

b.  Caldwell-Bradford School, 16401 Davidson-Concord Road, Davidson

Map of Property

Designation Report

SHPO Staff Comments

Designation would include the exterior of the building and the approximately 1.68 acres of land associated with tax parcel #01108107.

Staff Recommendation: In light of the discrepancy between the Historic Landmarks Commission’s unanimous August 12, 2024, decision to process the Caldwell-Bradford School for landmark designation and the North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office’s subsequent opinion that the Caldwell-Bradford School lacks historic integrity, Staff recommends that the Commission revisit the matter to determine by vote (1) the validity of SHPO’s opinion as to the Caldwell-Bradford School’s lack of historic integrity, in light of the designation report’s findings as to the building’s special local significance, and (2) whether to re-affirm or reverse its August 12, 2024, decision to process the Caldwell-Bradford School for landmark designation.

Caldwell-Bradford School

5.  Preliminary Review, Gama Goat Building at Camp North End, 1801 N. Graham Street, Charlotte 

6.  Steele Creek Church Easement and Douglas House Agreement

7.  Survey Committee Report: Tommy Warlick

Survey Committee Minutes

a.  Consideration of Designation Reports

Presentations on Designation Reports

i.  Armour Street Mill House, 225 Armour Street, Davidson

The Survey Committee presents a seconded motion recommending that the Historic Landmarks Commission process the Armour Street Mill House, 225 Armour Street, Davidson, N.C., for historic landmark designation including the exterior of the house and the associated tax parcel. The Committee unanimously approved this motion.   

Armour Street Mill House

ii.  Hunters Chapel United Methodist Church, 18423 John Connor Road, Cornelius  

The Survey Committee presents a seconded motion recommending that the Historic Landmarks Commission process the Hunters Chapel United Methodist Church, 18423 John Connor Road, Cornelius, N.C., for historic landmark designation including the interior and exterior of the church, the cemetery, and the associated tax parcel. The Committee unanimously approved this motion.  

Hunters Chapel United Methodist Church

b.  Alexander Farm Tenant House, 18324 W. Catawba Avenue, Cornelius 

Alexander Farm Tenant House

8.  Community Outreach Committee Report: Victoria Grey

9.  Financial Report: Stewart Gray

10.  Historic Landmarks Staff Report

a.  November 4 HLC Meeting Date and Location Change

b.  Donovan Rypkema Lecture Update 

11.  Old Business

12.  New Business


The Historic Landmarks Commission will meet on Monday, September 9 at 6pm. This will be a hybrid meeting and visitors should plan to access the meeting remotely. If you need special accommodations, please contact the Historic Landmarks office at 980-314-7660.

For those interested in speaking at the meeting, please register by 4pm on September 9 by emailing historiclandmarkscommission@mecknc.gov. Note: Registration in advance is required to make public comments.


1.  Adoption of the Consent Agenda

a.  Approval of August HLC Minutes

2.  Chair’s Report: Brian Clarke

3.  Public Comment Period

Registration in advance is required to make public comments. Public comments can be up to 3 minutes per person and there will be no response from Commissioners.  

4.  Quasi-Judicial Hearings

a.  Cornelius High School Agricultural Building, 21126 Catawba Avenue, Cornelius

Staff Report

b.  Thies Building, 500 N. Tryon Street, Charlotte

Staff Report

5.  The HLC will meet with legal counsel in closed session

6.  Designation Updates

a.  Recommendation to Amend the Motion for the John Eli Brattain House, 305 S. Main Street, Davidson

Revised Designation Report

Additional Information

John Eli Brattain House

b.  Review of Comments from the State Historic Preservation Office for the Caldwell-Bradford Schoolhouse, 16401 Davidson-Concord Road, Davidson 

Caldwell-Bradford School

7.  Survey Committee Report: Lesley Carroll

The Survey Committee will meet on Wednesday, September 25th at 6 p.m. 

8.  Community Outreach Committee Report: Victoria Grey

9.  Financial Report: Stewart Gray

10.  Historic Landmarks Staff Report

a.  November 4 HLC Meeting Date Change

b.  Donovan Rypkema Lecture Update 

c.  Pottstown Update

d.  Properties Updates

11.  Old Business

12.  New Business



The Historic Landmarks Commission will meet on Monday, August 12 at 6pm. This will be a hybrid meeting and visitors should plan to access the meeting remotely. If you need special accommodations, please contact the Historic Landmarks office at 980-314-7660.

For those interested in speaking at the meeting, please register by 4pm on August 12 by emailing historiclandmarkscommission@mecknc.gov. Note: Registration in advance is required to make public comments.


1.  Adoption of the Consent Agenda

a.  Approval of July HLC Minutes

2.  Chair’s Report: Brian Clarke

a.  New Commissioner Introductions

3.  Liz Morrell, Strategic Planning & Historic, Cultural and Community Resources Manager, Park and Recreation: Voice of Pottstown Survey Results 

4.  Public Comment Period

Registration in advance is required to make public comments. Public comments can be up to 3 minutes per person and there will be no response from Commissioners.

5.  Public Hearings

Registration in advance is encouraged but not required to speak during the Public Hearings. You may register by either emailing historiclandmarkscommission@mecknc.gov by 4pm on August 12 OR stating in the Teams chat BEFORE the Public Hearing starts that you want to speak. Public comments can be up to 3 minutes per person.  

a.  John Phillips Little Jr. House, 1136 Queens Road, Charlotte

Map of Property

Designation Report

SHPO Staff Comments

Designation would include the interior and exterior of the main house, the exterior of the servant’s quarters/guest house, and the land associated with the tax parcel #15304220. 

John Phillips Little Jr. House

b.  Alexander-Howell House, 250 Cherokee Road, Charlotte

Map of Property

Designation Report

SHPO Staff Comments

Designation would include the exterior and interior of the main house, including the specified architectural elements as detailed in the designation report, and the land associated with the tax parcel #15506261.

Alexander-Howell House

c.  Steele Creek Presbyterian Church and Cemetery, 7401 and 7407 Steele Creek Road, Charlotte

Map of Property

Amended Designation Report

SHPO Staff Comments

The current designation ordinance would be amended to de-designate the associated 23 acres as presented, while maintaining the original landmark designation as to the remaining approximately 14.245 acres, including the interior and exterior of the ca. 1889 sanctuary building, the ca. 1763 cemetery, and associated historic structures.   

Steele Creek Cemetery

6.  Quasi-Judicial Hearings

a.  Grinnell/General Fire Extinguisher Company, 1435 W. Morehead Street, Charlotte

Staff Report

Grinnell Video

b.  Cowans Ford Monument-Davidson College Monument, 14910 NC 73 Hwy, Huntersville

Staff Report

7.  Survey Committee Report: Lesley Carroll

Survey Committee Minutes

a.  Consideration of Designation Reports

Additional Images

i.  Caldwell-Bradford School, 16401 Davidson-Concord Road, Davidson

The Survey Committee presents a seconded motion recommending that the Historic Landmarks Commission process the Caldwell-Bradford School, 16401 Davidson-Concord Road, Davidson, N.C., for historic landmark designation including the exterior of the school and the associated tax parcel. The Committee unanimously approved this motion.

Caldwell-Bradford School

ii.  John Eli Brattain House, 305 S. Main Street, Davidson

The Survey Committee presents a seconded motion recommending that the Historic Landmarks Commission process the John Eli Brattain House, 305 S. Main Street, Davidson, N.C., for historic landmark designation including the interior and exterior of the house and the two tax parcels associated with the house. The Committee unanimously approved this motion.

John Eli Brattain House

iii.  Marsh House, 1642 Hertford Road, Charlotte

The Survey Committee presents a seconded motion recommending that the Historic Landmarks Commission process the Marion R. and Lavonne Marsh House, 1642 Hertford Road, Charlotte, N.C., for historic landmark designation including the interior and exterior of the house and the associated tax parcel. The Committee unanimously approved this motion.

Marion and Lavonne Marsh House

8.  Community Outreach Committee Report: Victoria Grey

9.  The HLC will go into closed session to discuss a potential project   

10.  Financial Report: Stewart Gray

11.  Historic Landmarks Staff Report

a.  November 4 HLC Meeting Date Change

b.  Charlotte Museum of History Preservation Committee Volunteer  

c.  HLC Logo

12.  Old Business

13.  New Business


The Historic Landmarks Commission will meet on Monday, July 8 at 6pm. This will be a hybrid meeting and visitors should plan to access the meeting remotely. If you need special accommodations, please contact the Historic Landmarks office at 980-314-7660.

For those interested in speaking at the meeting, please register by 4pm on July 8 by emailing historiclandmarkscommission@mecknc.gov. Note: Registration in advance is required to make public comments.


1.  Adoption of the Consent Agenda

a.  Approval of June HLC Minutes

2.  Chair’s Report: Victoria Grey as Acting Chair

3.  Public Comment Period

Registration in advance is required to make public comments. Public comments can be up to 3 minutes per person and there will be no response from Commissioners.

4.  Property Updates

a.  Rural Hill Dog Trot, Neck Road, Huntersville

b.  Sloan House, 230 South Main Street, Davidson

c.  Former Steele Creek Presbyterian Church, 7401 Steele Creek Road, Charlotte

Surveyed Plat

d.  Cornelius Agriculture Building, 21126 Catawba Avenue, Cornelius

5.  Survey Committee Report: Lesley Carroll

The Survey Committee will meet on Wednesday, July 24

a.  Scorpio Lounge, 2301 Freedom Drive, Charlotte

6.  Community Outreach Committee Report: Victoria Grey

7.  Closed Session  

8.  Historic Landmarks Staff Report

a.  November HLC Meeting Date

9.  Presentation of Commissioner Plaques

10.  Old Business

11.  New Business